Neenah, Wisconsin
Handcrafted cupcakes and custom celebration cakes made from scratch in Neenah, WI. Premium ingredients, thoughtful design, and flavors that make every occasion feel like yours.
About Us
JMW Custom Cupcakes and Cakes was born from a simple belief: that the best desserts come from real ingredients, real care, and a willingness to slow down. Located on Haylett Street in Neenah, we bake everything from scratch — no shortcuts, no preservatives, no compromises.
Whether it's a birthday that calls for something playful, a wedding that needs to look as elegant as it tastes, or a Tuesday that could use a little sweetness — we treat every order the same way: like it's for someone we know.
How It Works
Share the occasion, your flavor preferences, dietary needs, and any design ideas. We'll help you narrow it down and give you a clear quote.
Your order is baked from scratch in our Neenah kitchen the day before pickup or delivery. No shortcuts, no stale inventory — just real baking.
Pick up at our shop on Haylett Street, or we'll arrange local delivery for your event. Every cake is packed with care to arrive as beautiful as it was designed.
Our Work
JMW made our wedding cake and it was absolutely stunning — and everyone kept coming back for seconds. The flavor was rich without being heavy, and the design matched our vision perfectly. We couldn't have asked for more.
Get in Touch
Reach out by phone, email, or stop by the shop. We'd love to hear about your next celebration.
